Knowledge base · Out-of-court agreement and restructuring
When is an out-of-court agreement preferable, and when pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
An out-of-court agreement makes sense when there are few creditors, when they are willing to talk, and when the account is not blocked or the blocking is short. It is also the more discreet solution: the agreement remains between the company and its creditors, whereas pre-bankruptcy proceedings are published openly on the courts’ e-Notice Board. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are better when there are many creditors, when some refuse an agreement, or when the company needs protection from enforcement while the plan is being prepared.
There is no rule that always applies, but there are clear criteria. It helps to look at five things: how many creditors there are and how concentrated the debt is, how many days of the blocking of the account have already elapsed, whether assets have been pledged as security, how important discretion is towards customers and suppliers, and whether the key creditors will talk at all.
The out-of-court route suits cases where the key creditors are two or three banks and a few larger suppliers, where those parties know each other and are willing to talk, and where the blocking of the account is short or absent. Its advantages are speed, cost and discretion: the agreement stays between the parties, whereas the decision opening pre-bankruptcy proceedings and the proposed plan are published openly on the courts’ e-Notice Board.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are stronger when there are many creditors, when the debt is larger, or when one of the creditors blocks an agreement. Protection from enforcement and the binding effect of a confirmed plan provide a certainty that an out-of-court agreement does not.
The right answer comes only from analysing the situation: a list of creditors, a cash flow forecast and an assessment of their intentions. Both routes are often prepared in parallel, and the one that proves achievable is pursued.
This answer is general and does not replace advice on your specific case.
Arrange a confidential consultation
Other questions: Out-of-court agreement and restructuring
- Can a debt be resolved without going to court?
- What is a restructuring plan and what must it contain?
- How long does it take to prepare a restructuring plan?
- Is restructuring public?
- What is a standstill and how is it agreed?
- What is a debt-for-equity swap?
- What if a key creditor refuses an agreement?
- Is a partial debt write-off relevant for tax purposes?
All questions in the Knowledge base (89) →
The content of the Knowledge base is a copyrighted work of iNOVA. Short quotations are permitted provided the source is credited (iNOVA, Knowledge base, inova.com.hr) and the website is linked. Reproducing larger parts or any other use requires our written permission. More in the Legal Notice.