Knowledge base
Frequently asked questions about blocked accounts, pre-bankruptcy proceedings, financing and risk prevention
Short answers to the questions that owners and managers ask most often. The answers are general and do not replace advice on your own case.
The content of the Knowledge base is a copyrighted work of iNOVA. Short quotations are permitted provided the source is credited (iNOVA, Knowledge base, inova.com.hr) and the website is linked. Reproducing larger parts or any other use requires our written permission. More in the Legal Notice.
Blocked account and first signs of difficulty
The company’s account has been blocked. What should we do first?
Do not wait for the blocking of the account to resolve itself: the statutory deadlines run from the first day. In the first days, establish which creditors have enforcement orders registered against the account and for what amounts, list all of the company’s obligations and prepare a short-term cash flow forecast covering the next three months. Only with that information can you assess the options realistically.
In short, the first days are for establishing the company’s position. FINA (through its e-Dugovanja service) provides data on enforcement orders and the blocking of the account, so you can see how many creditors have enforced against the account and for what amounts. Then list all of your obligations, including those not yet subject to enforcement. Creditors who learn of account blocking often rush to collect, so it is better that you are the first to have the full picture.
The second step is a short-term cash flow forecast: a table showing, week by week, cash inflows and outflows, usually over the next quarter. It shows whether funds will be available for wages, taxes and key suppliers, and how much time you really have. Without such a forecast, every decision is guesswork.
The third step is caution. Before making larger payments, disposing of assets or granting guarantees, take expert advice, because some transactions made while a company is in difficulty can later be challenged. Only once you have the picture and the forecast does it make sense to choose a course: an agreement with creditors, pre-bankruptcy proceedings or another option. The earlier you start, the more options you have, because the statutory deadlines run from the first day of the blocking of the account.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 6(2); FINA, e-Dugovanja service.
How long can a company’s account stay blocked?
The honest answer: the shorter, the better. The first day of the blocking of the account, or better still before it, when blocking is imminent, is the moment to consider pre-bankruptcy proceedings, because one enforcement order quickly attracts others. After 60 days of unexecuted enforcement orders the law presumes that the company is unable to pay, which is a ground for bankruptcy, and pre-bankruptcy proceedings then become considerably harder to achieve.
Sixty days is not a period you are “allowed” to wait out calmly; it is the last deadline for a decision. That is why every day of account blocking narrows your options, rather than merely prolonging an unpleasant situation.
What happens when the deadline passes? The company is deemed unable to pay, as it is also if it has failed to pay three consecutive wages. The management board is then obliged to file a bankruptcy petition without delay and at the latest within 21 days (Art. 110(2)), and the presumption of imminent inability to pay required for pre-bankruptcy proceedings no longer applies (Art. 4(2)).
If the blocking of the account continues for 120 days without interruption, FINA itself files a petition to open bankruptcy within eight days (for companies without employees that do not meet the conditions for deletion from the court register, it files a request for shortened bankruptcy proceedings). Once bankruptcy is opened, management of the company and its assets pass to the bankruptcy trustee, and the owner and the management board lose their powers.
In practice: if the account is blocked or blocking is imminent, do not wait to see whether matters “sort themselves out”. Review your position, count the days that have already elapsed and decide on a course while there is still a choice.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 6(2), 110, 428 and 429; FINA, Bankruptcy proceedings.
How can serious difficulties be recognised before account blocking?
The clearest signs are late payment of taxes and contributions, supplier arrears of more than 60 days, wages paid late or in part, and old debts being repaid with new borrowing. When two or three of these signs appear, it is time to examine the figures, because that is when the range of options is widest.
Difficulties rarely arrive overnight. They are usually preceded by a series of small signals that are easily explained away as a “temporary situation”: a customer who pays late, a weaker season, a larger expense. Individually they are not dangerous, but together they indicate a widening gap between the funds available and the funds required.
Three questions an owner or the management board can ask themselves: Would we have funds for the next three months if we collected nothing? Who are our largest creditors, and how will they react if we are late? What happens if a key customer pays late or leaves? If you cannot answer any one of them, that is a sign the figures deserve closer examination.
From the point at which inability to pay becomes likely, the law requires the management board to take creditors’ interests into account and to take measures to avert it. The employer is also obliged to inform employees at least once a year about the early warning system and restructuring procedures. Acting early is therefore not only good practice but also a statutory expectation.
Reviewing the figures does not mean restructuring straight away. A discussion, a cash flow forecast and a few measures are often enough, and account blocking may never occur.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 7.a and 20.a.
Can account blocking be resolved by agreement with a creditor?
Yes. If you agree with a creditor on payment by instalments, a partial write-off or another solution, the creditor can withdraw the enforcement order from FINA, and the blocking of the account on that basis ends. Creditors are more willing to agree when they see precise figures and a credible plan than when they receive only a request for a postponement.
A creditor wants to be paid, not to block your account. If an agreement looks realistic, they will often prefer instalments to waiting for the outcome of proceedings. The difference lies in what they receive: a request for a postponement, or an offer with figures, deadlines and an explanation of how the company will perform it.
The agreement is put in writing. Once the creditor withdraws the enforcement order from FINA, the blocking of the account on that basis ends. But where several orders are registered, the account is unblocked only when all of them have been resolved. The agreement must therefore be planned for every creditor registered with FINA, not only the largest.
A few practical points: agree in writing, because an oral promise is hard to prove. Offer only what you can genuinely perform, because a broken agreement forfeits the trust of that creditor and of others. And consider how an agreement with one creditor will look to the others, because some transactions made in difficulty can later be challenged.
Where there are many creditors, or some refuse to negotiate, an out-of-court agreement often fails, so we advise preparing for pre-bankruptcy proceedings in parallel.
Is a director personally liable if the company fails to meet its obligations?
In certain cases, yes. The greatest risk arises when the management board fails to act in time, continues to incur obligations the company cannot pay, or does not file a bankruptcy petition when required. Acting early, with expert advice, is the best protection for the company and its management board alike.
The company and its directors are separate legal persons: as a rule, the company, not a board member, is liable for the company’s debts. That protection has limits. The law provides for the personal liability of management board members in certain cases, and the court decides on it according to the circumstances of each case.
That is why there is no simple “yes” or “no”. The risk is greater when the board sees that the company cannot pay and still keeps incurring new obligations, when it conceals the company’s situation, when it pays some creditors to the detriment of others, or when it fails to file a bankruptcy petition at the moment it is required to.
What helps: monitor liquidity regularly, record the reasons for important decisions, seek expert advice early and choose a course in good time, whether an agreement, pre-bankruptcy proceedings or bankruptcy. Documented, considered decisions place you in a far better position than decisions taken in panic.
This is a legal question. An assessment of personal liability in a specific case is given by a lawyer; alongside the lawyer, we prepare the figures and the plan.
Who can block a company’s account, and on what basis?
A company’s account is blocked by FINA when there are insufficient funds in the account to execute the enforcement orders it has received. Enforcement orders include, for example, an enforceable decision of a court or administrative body, a settlement, a promissory note or blank promissory note, an enforcement or security order, or an employer’s statement on unpaid wages.
FINA enforces without the debtor’s consent and against all of the debtor’s accounts by personal identification number (OIB). It records orders in the Register in the order of receipt (date, hour and minute) and executes them in the order in which they were recorded.
A creditor therefore does not block the account itself: it submits the enforcement order (an enforceable decision, a promissory note and the like) to FINA, which records and executes it. Once blocked, the account remains blocked until all orders have been executed or discontinued, or until one of the statutory grounds for termination occurs, for example the opening of pre-bankruptcy proceedings.
For unpaid wages, the employer must itself file a request for enforced collection with FINA on the next working day. If it does not, the labour inspectorate may by decision prohibit the disposal of money in its accounts, regardless of whether they are blocked.
Source: Act on Enforcement on Monetary Funds (OG 68/18, 2/20, 46/20, 47/20), Art. 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7; Act on Securing Workers' Claims (OG 70/17, 18/23), Art. 33 and 36.
May a company pay wages and suppliers while its account is blocked?
From a blocked account the debtor cannot itself choose whom to pay: incoming funds are applied to enforcement orders not yet executed, in the order in which they were recorded. For unpaid wages the law nevertheless provides a special route: the employer must immediately, and at the latest within three days of the day on which it was established that the enforcement order could not be executed, submit to the Agency for Securing Workers’ Claims a collective request for payment of wages at the level of the minimum wage for all employees whose wages have not been paid.
Enforcement extends to all of the company’s accounts, so it is not enough to open a new account at another bank. FINA executes orders in the order of recording, unless another law provides otherwise (Art. 7). Banks report every inflow into a blocked account to FINA, and the inflow is applied exclusively to unexecuted orders (Art. 9(8) and (9)).
Together with the collective request the employer attaches, among other things, a list of employees with amounts, transfer orders, JOPPD forms and FINA's confirmation that the accounts are blocked. This route does not apply to an employee to whom the employer has paid at least the minimum wage. At the Agency's request the employer must within eight days supply all the data needed for the procedure; if it does not, it faces a fine of 390 to 1,320 euros, and the responsible person 130 to 390 euros (Art. 38). For the company this means that wages and key suppliers must be dealt with before account blocking. Once pre-bankruptcy proceedings have been opened, FINA continues to handle requests for enforced collection of wages as before. How wages are handled during pre-bankruptcy proceedings is covered by a separate question in this group.
Source: Act on Securing Workers' Claims (OG 70/17, 18/23), Art. 33 and 38; Act on Enforcement on Monetary Funds (OG 68/18, 2/20, 46/20, 47/20), Art. 3, 4, 7 and 9.
Can a company in pre-bankruptcy proceedings obtain new financing, and are advisers’ fees protected?
Yes, under the conditions set by law. The company may incur new debt for interim financing if creditors holding more than two thirds of the established claims approve it in writing, and the financing is justified and urgently needed to continue operations. If bankruptcy is later opened, such payments are, as a rule, not capable of being challenged.
The creditors’ consent is given in writing, at the latest at the hearing on voting on the plan. Within three days the court checks whether the required majority of creditors has consented and whether the borrowing is justified and urgently needed, and then determines by decision the amounts, terms and repayment deadlines. New financing needed to implement the plan may also be provided for in the restructuring plan itself.
If bankruptcy is later opened, claims arising from such financing rank ahead of other bankruptcy creditors, except for creditors in the first higher payment rank (primarily employees).
A separate rule protects other restructuring-related payments. Transactions that are justified and urgently needed for negotiations on the plan cannot be challenged in a subsequent bankruptcy. The examples listed in the law include fees and costs connected with negotiating, adopting or confirming the plan, fees for expert advice closely connected with the restructuring, wages for work already performed and other payments in the ordinary course of business. The exceptions are a criminal offence, a breach of good faith and fair dealing, and a conflict of interest on the part of the counterparty.
The protection applies only to payments that are genuinely justified and urgent. It is not a general guarantee that no payment made while in difficulty will later be challenged.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 62.a and 62.b.
Can payments and transfers of assets made before bankruptcy later be reversed?
Yes. If bankruptcy is opened, the bankruptcy trustee or creditors may bring an action to challenge legal acts undertaken before the opening that harmed creditors or placed some of them in a more favourable position. The look-back periods run from the filing of the bankruptcy petition and depend on the type of act: most often three months, four years for gifts and up to ten years for an act done with intent to harm creditors.
Examples from the law: a payment to a creditor within the last three months can be challenged if the company was then unable to pay and the creditor knew it. A payment to which the creditor was not entitled, or not in that form or at that time, can be challenged if made in the last month, and in the second and third months under additional conditions. A transaction that directly harms creditors can be challenged within three months under the same conditions. An act without consideration or for negligible consideration can be challenged up to four years back (except for the customary occasional gift of negligible value). An act done with intent to harm can be challenged up to ten years back if the counterparty knew of that intent.
Closely related persons are treated more strictly. In a company these are members of the management board and supervisory bodies, persons holding more than a quarter of the share capital, and persons whose position or employment gives them insight into the company’s situation. For closely related persons the law presumes knowledge of the inability to pay. A shareholder loan that replaces capital is also subject to special rules.
If pre-bankruptcy proceedings preceded the bankruptcy, the periods run back from the filing of the petition for pre-bankruptcy proceedings. An action may be brought within two years of the opening of bankruptcy. If the challenge succeeds, the act has no effect against the bankruptcy estate and the counterparty must return what it received, whereupon its claim is revived.
Payments under Art. 62.b (transactions needed for negotiations on the restructuring plan) are protected. That is why, before making larger payments, disposing of assets or granting guarantees while in difficulty, it pays to consult an expert.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 198–203, 207, 208(3), 212 and 62.b.
How does bankruptcy differ from pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
Both pre-bankruptcy proceedings and bankruptcy are court proceedings. In pre-bankruptcy proceedings the company continues to be run by its management board, under the supervision of the pre-bankruptcy trustee. In bankruptcy the company is run by the bankruptcy trustee in place of the management board. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings allow the company to agree a plan with its creditors and continue operating. Bankruptcy serves the collective satisfaction of creditors: the assets are liquidated and the proceeds distributed to creditors. The two proceedings cannot run concurrently: while pre-bankruptcy proceedings are under way, bankruptcy proceedings may not be commenced, and once bankruptcy proceedings have been commenced, pre-bankruptcy proceedings may not be commenced.
The ground for pre-bankruptcy proceedings is imminent inability to pay. The grounds for bankruptcy are inability to pay and over-indebtedness. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings can be commenced only by the debtor, whereas bankruptcy can be commenced by a creditor or the debtor. FINA is obliged to file a bankruptcy petition if the account has been blocked without interruption for 120 days.
In pre-bankruptcy proceedings the management board remains at the head of the company, supervised by the pre-bankruptcy trustee. In bankruptcy the bankruptcy trustee takes over the rights and obligations of the debtor’s corporate bodies. Once bankruptcy is closed, the legal entity is deleted from the register and ceases to exist.
The management board must file a bankruptcy petition without delay and at the latest within 21 days of a ground for bankruptcy arising; otherwise it is personally liable to creditors for the resulting damage.
Even bankruptcy does not always mean the end of the company. After bankruptcy is opened, a bankruptcy plan may be prepared under which, among other things, the debtor can retain assets in order to continue operating, and in certain cases the court may allow the debtor to manage itself under the supervision of the bankruptcy trustee (a “debtor in possession”: the debtor stays in charge). If pre-bankruptcy proceedings fail, the court discontinues them and continues ex officio as if a bankruptcy petition had been filed, unless the company has in the meantime become able to pay and has settled all of its obligations.
In bankruptcy, the costs of the proceedings and the liabilities of the bankruptcy estate are satisfied first, followed by employees and other creditors according to their payment ranks.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 2, 4–7, 15, 64(2), 88(1), 109, 110, 138, 154, 286(3), 303 and 356.
What happens with customers and suppliers when the blocking of the account becomes known?
When account blocking becomes known, customers and suppliers lose confidence and become more cautious. Suppliers most often refuse further deliveries and ask for additional security or alternative ways of payment. That is why it is advisable for key partners to hear about the blocking from you first, and not from other sources.
In our experience, a company that calmly explains what is happening and how it will be resolved, with a concrete plan, retains more trust than one that stays silent until its partners find out otherwise.
Before that discussion you need to know three things: how large the blocked amount is, how long it can last and what the company can promise. Do not promise deadlines you cannot meet.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings
What are pre-bankruptcy proceedings and what are they for?
It is a court procedure in which a company facing imminent inability to pay agrees a restructuring plan with its creditors: rescheduling, a partial write-off or conversion of debt. The management board continues to run the business, and the court appoints a pre-bankruptcy trustee who supervises operations. The aim is for the company to continue operating rather than end up in bankruptcy. For readers familiar with US law: in spirit, the procedure is comparable to a Chapter 11 reorganisation (the debtor stays in charge under court supervision, creditors vote on a plan and the court confirms it), but it is a distinct procedure under Croatian law, with its own rules and time limits.
Think of pre-bankruptcy proceedings as structured negotiations with creditors under the court’s umbrella. The company proposes a plan: how it will operate, what it will pay, when, and what creditors will receive of their claims. Creditors vote on the plan, and the court confirms it.
The main stages are: the petition to open proceedings, the opening, the filing and examination of claims, negotiations on the plan, the creditors’ vote and confirmation of the plan. Throughout, the company keeps operating, the management board remains at the head, and the pre-bankruptcy trustee supervises, in particular payments.
The main advantage: a confirmed plan binds all creditors it concerns, including those who voted against it or did not take part. That is why pre-bankruptcy proceedings can succeed even when an out-of-court agreement with every creditor cannot be reached.
For the owner or the management board this means: the company has a chance to keep operating, and creditors receive a structured and verifiable route to satisfaction, usually better than in bankruptcy. The law also protects the creditor: a creditor who objects to the plan and shows it is probable that the plan leaves them worse off than without a plan can ask the court to refuse confirmation. The outcome is never guaranteed, because it depends on creditors and the court.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 2, 4, 22–24, 61(4) and (5) and Art. 62(1).
Is a pre-bankruptcy settlement the same as pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
In everyday speech, yes. The pre-bankruptcy settlement was a procedure under the law that was in force until 2015; today the procedure is called pre-bankruptcy proceedings and is regulated by the Bankruptcy Act. The goal is the same, but the rules are different: today the commercial court decides on all matters.
Many people still say “pre-bankruptcy settlement” because the term remained from the period when the procedure was conducted under another law. That is understandable, because the idea itself stayed the same: the debtor and creditors agree a plan, and if the plan meets the prescribed conditions, it binds all creditors.
Today the procedure is called pre-bankruptcy proceedings and is regulated by the Bankruptcy Act. It is conducted by the commercial court, and the court appoints the pre-bankruptcy trustee. FINA still has a role, for example in recording enforcement orders and in the tables of filed claims, but the court decides on the opening of proceedings, the plan and its confirmation.
For you as an owner or board member the difference is practical: when you read old articles and guides, bear in mind that the rules have changed in the meantime. That is why we take care to rely on the law currently in force, not on older texts.
If you have read the term “pre-bankruptcy settlement” somewhere, that does not mean the text is bad. Just check when it was written and whether it refers to today's law.
When should a company enter pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
As early as possible, the moment the first signs appear. The law allows pre-bankruptcy proceedings when the company faces imminent inability to pay, and the signs are concrete: unexecuted enforcement orders registered with FINA, wages more than 30 days late, or taxes and contributions unpaid 30 days after the due date of the wage. Each of these signs is a trigger for a decision, not a reason to wait.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are not a last resort but a tool for a company that still has something to save. They are best considered while the company is still operating, still has customers and employees, and its creditors are still willing to talk.
The decision is easiest when three conditions coincide: the company has a viable core business, it has too many creditors to deal with through an out-of-court agreement, and there is enough time to prepare a plan.
After 60 days of unexecuted enforcement orders, the law presumes inability to pay, which is a ground for bankruptcy. The management board must then file a bankruptcy petition within 21 days, and the presumption of imminent inability to pay on which pre-bankruptcy proceedings are based no longer applies (Art. 4(2)), so pre-bankruptcy proceedings become considerably harder to achieve. Grounds for bankruptcy can also arise before 60 days, for example where the company has failed to pay three consecutive wages, so the 60 days should not be treated as time that may be used up in full. A new pre-bankruptcy procedure is not possible until two years have passed since the obligations under a confirmed plan were fulfilled, so the plan must be realistic.
If you are unsure, reviewing the figures and speaking with an adviser and a lawyer is cheaper than waiting. The decision to file is a legal matter: the petition is signed and filed by the debtor. We recommend that you consult a lawyer on it.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 4, 6, 32 and 110(2).
Who starts pre-bankruptcy proceedings and what has to be enclosed?
The petition is filed only by the debtor, with the commercial court, on the prescribed form. It must be accompanied by financial statements no more than three months old, a list of assets and liabilities, a statement of the number of employees and, if ready, a restructuring plan.
Proceedings can be commenced only by the company as debtor, not by a creditor. The decision and the initiative therefore lie with the management board. The petition is filed with the commercial court on the prescribed form, and in practice the legal work is usually entrusted to a lawyer.
The petition must be accompanied by financial statements no more than three months old, a list of assets and liabilities, a statement of the number of employees and, if ready, a restructuring plan. The court decides on opening within eight days of receiving a proper petition.
If the plan is not filed with the petition, the debtor must submit it at the latest within 21 days of the finality of the decision on established and disputed claims. If the debtor does not submit, within that period, a plan covering all established and disputed claims, the court discontinues the proceedings. It is therefore advisable to prepare the plan before the petition is filed, so that the deadline does not become a burden.
Creditors cannot prevent the proceedings from being opened, but they vote on the plan later. The division of work we recommend: the lawyer handles the legal part and the filing, and the financial adviser prepares the figures, the plan and communication with creditors.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 16, 25, 26 and 52; FINA.
How much do pre-bankruptcy proceedings cost, and what must be paid?
A court fee of 280 euros and an advance on the costs of the proceedings of 660 euros are paid with the petition. If the advance is not paid, the court rejects the petition as inadmissible. In addition there are FINA’s fee, the pre-bankruptcy trustee’s fee, and the costs of advisers and lawyers.
The court fee for a petition to open pre-bankruptcy proceedings is 280 euros. It is payable on petitions filed from 1 June 2026, when the new Regulation on the Tariff of Court Fees entered into force.
The advance on the costs of the proceedings is 660 euros and is paid by the petitioner. Where there are several petitioners, they pay the advance in equal shares. If the advance is not paid, the court rejects the petition as inadmissible.
The fee to FINA for its work in the proceedings is prescribed by a separate ordinance.
The pre-bankruptcy trustee’s remuneration and reimbursement of expenses are determined under the rules that apply to the bankruptcy trustee.
Advisers’ and lawyers’ costs are not prescribed by law but agreed by contract. Their amount depends on the size of the company, the number of creditors and the scope of the work.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 23 and 28; Regulation on the Tariff of Court Fees (OG 50/2026), Tariff item 22.
Is the account unblocked when pre-bankruptcy proceedings are opened?
Yes, but not automatically, not indefinitely and not for everything. Enforcement proceedings are interrupted on the day of opening, and from receipt of the court’s decision FINA stops executing enforcement orders against the company. The protection lasts 120 days, and the court can extend it at most twice by 90 days, up to 300 days in total. It does not cover everything: FINA still executes orders for wages, severance pay, child maintenance and security measures in criminal proceedings, and the court may also lift the prohibition.
This is one of the most important benefits of pre-bankruptcy proceedings, but also the point at which it is easiest to go wrong. When proceedings are opened, enforcement is interrupted and FINA stops executing enforcement orders against the company’s account. The company thereby gains time to prepare a plan and conduct negotiations.
There are exceptions. FINA still executes orders for unpaid wages, wage compensation and severance pay, and for child maintenance and security measures in criminal proceedings, and certain creditors (for example, for compensation for a workplace injury) may, through the pre-bankruptcy trustee, request that collection continue. FINA does not record new orders during the protection period.
The protection lasts 120 days. At the request of the company, a creditor or the pre-bankruptcy trustee, the court may extend it twice by 90 days each if negotiations are progressing, giving 300 days in total at most. The extension request must be filed at least 15 days before the deadline expires. If FINA does not receive the extension decision in time, collection from the account resumes. The court may also lift the prohibition if creditors who are able to block the plan do not support the negotiations.
In practice, therefore, the first days after opening and each extension deadline must be watched closely, and the plan and negotiations conducted so as to show progress.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 68 and 69 (consolidated text, OG 71/15, 36/22); amendments: Act Amending the Bankruptcy Act, OG 36/22, Art. 42 and 44.
How long do pre-bankruptcy proceedings last?
The law requires them to be completed within 120 days of opening. The court may extend the period by at most a further 180 days if the proceedings are progressing, so the upper limit is 300 days. If creditors do not accept the plan and the statutory deadlines leave no time for a new vote, the court finds that creditors will not accept the plan, the proceedings are discontinued and the court continues them ex officio as if a petition to open bankruptcy had been filed: in practice the company then most often enters bankruptcy.
The basic period is 120 days from opening. The court may extend it by at most 180 days if the proceedings are progressing, so the upper limit is 300 days from opening.
The stay on enforcement also lasts 120 days and may be extended by the court twice by 90 days each. The company therefore has limited time, which must be borne in mind when planning.
Filing and examination of claims and negotiations on the plan take the most time. That is why it is crucial for the plan and the figures to be ready before the petition. A company that enters the proceedings with a ready plan saves weeks, and in pre-bankruptcy proceedings that is precious.
If the debtor fulfils all obligations towards creditors by the voting hearing, the court discontinues the proceedings. If in doing so it finds that the debtor is able to pay and has fulfilled all obligations towards creditors, the proceedings are not continued as bankruptcy.
What this means in practice: do not count on the proceedings “dragging on” in your favour. Every day has its task, and the deadlines are stricter than they appear when the proceedings are commenced.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 63, 64 and 68(2).
Can the company operate normally during pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
Yes, but with restrictions. From the filing of the petition the company may make only payments necessary for ordinary business. Until the proceedings are opened it may not dispose of or encumber assets, and after opening it may do so only with the pre-bankruptcy trustee’s prior approval. From opening it may not discharge obligations that arose and fell due before opening, except those the law lists, for example employees’ wages. Other such claims are dealt with under the plan. The pre-bankruptcy trustee supervises operations, in particular financial operations and the incurring of new obligations.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are not a halt to business. The company keeps operating: it produces, sells, collects, and pays wages and essential costs. The company’s own debtors keep paying it, and the court expressly calls on them to do so in the decision opening the proceedings.
The law lists the following as necessary: gross payments from employment to current and former employees, severance pay up to the amount prescribed by law and the collective agreement, compensation for damage caused by a workplace injury or occupational disease, wages and other employee entitlements that fell due after the petition was filed, the costs of the pre-bankruptcy proceedings, and other payments necessary for ordinary business prescribed by a special law.
From opening, obligations that arose and fell due before opening may not be discharged, except those listed in the previous paragraph. Others are dealt with under the restructuring plan. The debtor may sell or encumber assets only with the prior approval of the pre-bankruptcy trustee or, if none has been appointed, of the court.
That is why wages are the first thing that must be paid properly: if during the proceedings the debtor is more than 30 days late with a wage that fell due after opening, or does not pay contributions and taxes within that period, the court will discontinue the proceedings.
The debtor must be able to prove that a payment was necessary for ordinary business, and the court assesses that. Inability to prove it can result in the pre-bankruptcy proceedings being discontinued.
The pre-bankruptcy trustee supervises operations, in particular financial operations and the incurring of new obligations, and the settlement of the costs of the proceedings. In practice this means that the management board should keep proper records, report regularly to the pre-bankruptcy trustee and think in advance about every unusual expense. In our experience it is best to ask for the pre-bankruptcy trustee’s written consent in advance for all payments.
Good practice is to keep records by category: payments in the ordinary course of business, obligations that arose before opening (which are not paid, except those the law allows, for example an employee’s wage) and everything that goes beyond the usual. In that way the management board can readily show that it acted in accordance with the rules, and the pre-bankruptcy trustee and creditors retain confidence in the company.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 24, 29, 64 and 67.
How many creditors must accept the plan?
Creditors vote in classes. The plan is accepted when both conditions are met in every class: a majority of creditors (by number) have voted for the plan and their claims make up more than two thirds of the total claims in that class. A creditor who does not vote is counted as having voted for the plan.
Creditors are divided into classes according to the similar legal position of their claims, for example secured and unsecured creditors. Both conditions must be met in every class: the plan must be supported by a majority of creditors by number and by more than two thirds of claims by amount. One condition without the other is not enough. So it is not only the number of creditors that counts, but also how much they are owed.
Creditors vote in writing, on the prescribed form, which must reach the court before the voting hearing begins. A creditor who does not submit the form, or submits it in such a way that it cannot be established beyond doubt how they voted, is regarded as having voted for the plan. That is why creditors who do not respond at all are also counted towards the plan. The form does not have to arrive by post in advance. In practice creditors often hand it to the court just before the hearing, that is, just before the vote on the plan. The voting hearing must be held no later than 30 days from the finality of the decision on established and disputed claims.
Example: creditors in one class together hold claims of 900,000 euros. The plan passes if those in favour hold claims of more than 600,000 euros. The law puts it this way: the sum of the claims of creditors who voted for the plan is more than double the sum of the claims of those who voted against.
That is why it is important to explain the plan and the voting procedure to creditors in good time.
Under the conditions set out in the law, the court can confirm the plan even if a class has not accepted it. This prevents one class from blocking a good plan, but that route requires careful preparation and reasoning.
That is why we write the plan not only for the court but also for creditors: who they are, what they want and what the plan offers them compared with bankruptcy. The more the large creditors are convinced, the more likely the plan is to pass.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 55, 58, 59 and 59.a.
Do creditors have to file their claims?
Yes. Under the law, in its decision opening the proceedings the court calls on creditors to file their claims with FINA within 21 days of delivery of the decision. Filing is in their own interest: a creditor who has not filed a claim does not take part in the vote on the plan, and claims can be pursued only within the pre-bankruptcy proceedings. After the proceedings end, the creditor can be satisfied only as the plan provides for its class of creditors.
Filing of claims is the step in which it is established who the creditors are and how much each claims. Creditors file them with FINA.
When must a creditor file a claim? The deadline is 21 days from delivery of the decision opening the proceedings. The court does not send the decision by post but publishes it on the courts’ e-Notice Board, and delivery is deemed made when the eighth day after publication expires. The 21-day period starts to run only then, so the deadline should not be counted from the day of publication: about four weeks pass from publication to the last day for filing.
FINA draws up tables of filed claims, and the debtor, the pre-bankruptcy trustee and creditors can dispute them within the statutory deadlines. A creditor who has not filed a claim does not take part in the proceedings, including the vote on the plan. After the proceedings end, the creditor can be satisfied only as the plan provides for its class of creditors.
What this means for the company: the filed amounts should be compared with your own books. If a claim appears that you consider incorrect or unfounded, it must be disputed in good time. A missed deadline cannot be made up.
The table of filed claims is also the basis for the calculations in the plan: it shows how much is owed and to whom, and which classes of creditors exist. That is why the examination of claims is one of the most important parts of the proceedings.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 12, 34, 47, 56, 62 and 106(1).
What about wages and employees during pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
Wages must continue to be paid, because they are part of ordinary business. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings do not affect employees’ claims, including wages not paid before the proceedings were opened: these cannot be the subject of the plan. The plan must describe the effects on employment and how employees will be informed and consulted.
For employees, pre-bankruptcy proceedings usually mean nothing dramatic: they keep working, and wages are paid as before. Wages are part of ordinary business and among the first obligations to be paid. Even during the protection period, FINA continues to execute orders for unpaid wages, wage compensation and severance pay.
The law expressly provides that pre-bankruptcy proceedings do not affect the claims of current and former employees from employment in gross amount, severance pay up to the amount prescribed by law or the collective agreement, and compensation for damage caused by a workplace injury or occupational disease. Those claims cannot be the subject of the restructuring plan, so wages found to be unpaid before opening are neither written off nor rescheduled by the plan.
The restructuring plan must describe the possible effects on employment, for example dismissals or shorter working time, and how employees will be informed and consulted. Measures that change employment contracts require the employees’ consent. If during the proceedings the company is more than 30 days late with a wage that arose after the proceedings were opened, or does not pay taxes and contributions on that wage, the court discontinues the pre-bankruptcy proceedings.
How to communicate: honestly and on time. Employees who first hear about the proceedings from the media or from suppliers lose trust, and trust is key in a restructuring. That is why we plan in advance who says what to employees, and when.
Advice on labour matters (dismissals, collective agreements) is a legal field handled by lawyers, and we prepare the figures and the plan.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 27, 29, 64, 66 and 69.
Can a sole trader enter pre-bankruptcy proceedings too?
Yes. The law allows pre-bankruptcy proceedings for an individual debtor, that is, a natural person liable to income tax on self-employment, such as a sole trader (obrtnik), and a natural person liable to profit tax. The proceedings are nevertheless more complex, because a sole trader has no separate business assets.
A sole trader is a natural person who operates in their own name and is therefore liable for the business’s debts with all of their property. That is exactly why the proceedings are more sensitive for a sole trader: unlike a company, there is no distinction between business assets and private assets.
The law allows pre-bankruptcy proceedings for an individual debtor, that is, a natural person liable to income tax on self-employment, such as a sole trader, and a natural person liable to profit tax. The proceedings follow the same framework as for companies, but in practice questions of property, guarantees and family are more complex.
In the proceedings, a sole trader’s creditors file only claims arising from, or connected with, the performance of their activity (Art. 36(3)), while the sole trader is liable for them with all of their property.
What this means: a sole trader who sees difficulties should review the figures and speak to experts even earlier, because the consequences are more personal. A lawyer assesses what can and cannot be done, and an adviser prepares the financial part.
Our services are primarily intended for companies, but we talk to sole traders as well and assess each case individually.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 3 and 36.
Can a sole trader be released from debts that bankruptcy does not manage to pay?
Yes, but only an individual debtor, for example a sole trader, and under the conditions set by law. A sole trader who enters bankruptcy can request release from obligations to bankruptcy creditors that remain unsatisfied in the bankruptcy. For this they must, for three years from the opening of bankruptcy, assign part of their income to the bankruptcy trustee and, during that period, fulfil the statutory duties.
The request is filed together with the bankruptcy petition and, if someone else filed the petition, at the latest 15 days after the court’s instruction. The request must be accompanied by a declaration assigning attachable claims from employment or other current income for three years from the opening of bankruptcy. If release has already been granted to the debtor once, the assignment lasts five years, and release is not permitted if in the last ten years the debtor was already released or was refused release.
During the assignment period, the debtor must engage in suitable work or look for suitable employment, hand over to the bankruptcy trustee half of any inherited property and the entire value of any gift or winnings, report any change of residence or employment, and must not give any creditor a special advantage.
The court may refuse release at a creditor’s request, for example if the debtor has been finally convicted of a criminal offence against property or the economy; if in the last three years they gave incorrect or incomplete information about their situation in order to obtain credit or avoid paying public charges; if they took on inappropriate obligations or squandered property; or if they delayed the opening of bankruptcy with no prospect of improvement.
Release does not apply to secured claims, damage from an intentionally committed unlawful act, fines, maintenance, claims arising after the opening of bankruptcy and the costs of the bankruptcy proceedings. It also does not affect creditors' rights against guarantors and co-debtors. A ban on carrying out an activity imposed solely because of insolvency ceases to apply when the release becomes final.
Without release, after bankruptcy is closed creditors can enforce the remaining claims against an individual debtor without limit. When bankruptcy is closed, the sole trader loses the status of a sole trader.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 286(3), 287, 372–376, 381, 387 and 388.
Who is the pre-bankruptcy trustee and what do they do?
The pre-bankruptcy trustee is appointed by the court in the decision opening the pre-bankruptcy proceedings. The pre-bankruptcy trustee supervises the debtor’s operations and verifies claims.
The law requires the pre-bankruptcy trustee, among other things, to examine the debtor’s operations and its list of assets and liabilities, to verify the credibility of filed claims and dispute those whose existence they doubt, and to supervise operations, in particular financial operations and the incurring of new obligations.
The pre-bankruptcy trustee reports to the court a debtor who acts contrary to the law, issues the necessary orders and certificates, supervises the settlement of the costs of the proceedings and reports regularly to the court. During negotiations the pre-bankruptcy trustee can take over part of the management of assets and affairs, except for matters over which the debtor retains free disposal.
At the hearing on voting on the plan, the pre-bankruptcy trustee must, after the debtor’s presentation, give an opinion on the plan. For the company this means that the pre-bankruptcy trustee sees all the figures. The pre-bankruptcy trustee is obliged to assist the debtor in preparing the restructuring plan and in negotiations on it. Open and timely cooperation with the pre-bankruptcy trustee makes the whole procedure easier.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 24, 33 and 55(4).
What happens to enforcement proceedings and lawsuits when the proceedings are opened?
When pre-bankruptcy proceedings are opened, civil and arbitration proceedings, and enforcement and security proceedings against the debtor, are interrupted, and new ones cannot be commenced for claims affected by the proceedings. The stay on enforcement lasts 120 days, with the court able to extend it twice by 90 days each.
Interrupted civil and arbitration proceedings resume only after a pre-bankruptcy agreement has been reached on the disputed claims, or after the decision discontinuing the proceedings becomes final. The stay does not apply to proceedings concerning claims arising after the proceedings were opened.
If the court confirms the plan, it continues the interrupted lawsuits and dismisses claims to the extent covered by the plan, and discontinues enforcement and security accordingly. The proceedings do not affect security measures in criminal proceedings, tax proceedings to determine abuse of rights, or administrative proceedings of the Ministry of Finance and the Tax Administration to determine tax liabilities.
What exactly FINA still executes (for example wages) is covered by the answer on unblocking the account.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 68 and 68.a.
May a supplier stop deliveries because of an old debt after pre-bankruptcy proceedings are opened?
No. Once pre-bankruptcy proceedings are opened, a supplier under a contract concluded before opening and not yet fully performed may not, because of an unpaid debt, refuse delivery, terminate the contract, declare the debt due or change the contract to the company's detriment. If it nevertheless does so, such conduct has no legal effect.
Contracts that are necessary for ordinary business enjoy particular protection, including supply contracts whose interruption could bring the business to a halt. A supplier may not rely even on a contractual clause that ties suspension or termination to the filing of the petition for pre-bankruptcy proceedings or to their opening, and contractual provisions that exclude this in advance have no legal effect.
The protection applies to debt that arose before the proceedings were opened. Obligations that arise after opening must be paid by the company regularly: before the proceedings are concluded, it must settle the costs of the proceedings and the undisputed claims that fell due after opening.
The rules do not apply to exchange-traded and similar fixed-term transactions or to financial contracts (e.g. securities, foreign currency, options), as described in Art. 182(1)–(4) of the Bankruptcy Act.
What happens if a supplier nevertheless stops delivering (e.g. compensation or a penalty) is not prescribed by the law in those articles. The law says only that such conduct has no legal effect.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 67.a, 74.a(2) and Art. 182(1)–(4).
Can claims be disputed, and how?
Yes. A creditor has 15 days from delivery of the debtor’s and the pre-bankruptcy trustee’s statements to dispute claims it considers non-existent, stating the amount and the grounds for the dispute. The debtor and the pre-bankruptcy trustee have 30 days from delivery of the table of filed claims to state, for each claim, whether they admit or dispute it.
The statement is submitted to FINA on the prescribed form and, for each claim, contains the number from the table of filed claims, the creditor’s details and a statement of whether the claim is admitted or disputed. A dispute must state the amount and the grounds. After the deadline for statements expires, the debtor and the pre-bankruptcy trustee can no longer dispute claims they have admitted.
Between the last day of the deadline for disputing claims and the hearing to examine claims, at least eight and at most 15 days must pass. Deadlines should therefore be monitored from day one, and the filed amounts compared with your own books.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 34 and 41.
What if creditors do not accept the plan?
If the court finds that creditors will not accept the plan, it discontinues the pre-bankruptcy proceedings and continues them ex officio as if a petition to open bankruptcy had been filed, unless it finds that the debtor is able to pay and has fulfilled all obligations towards creditors.
That is why it is best to prepare the plan so that it presents creditors with a realistic picture and demonstrates that they are not placed in a worse position than without the plan (Art. 61(4)) and, ideally, that it offers them more than they would receive in bankruptcy. How voting works and how many creditors must accept the plan is covered by a separate question in this group.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 61(4), Art. 63 and 64.
What about guarantors and the directors’ personal liability during pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
The management board has statutory duties as soon as inability to pay becomes likely: it must take creditors’ interests into account, take measures to avoid inability to pay, and refrain from intentional acts or acts of gross negligence that endanger the viability of the business. When a ground for bankruptcy arises (inability to pay or over-indebtedness), the management board must file a petition to open bankruptcy without delay and at the latest within 21 days. If it does not, it is personally liable to creditors for the damage thereby caused to them (Art. 110).
These duties apply to the directors, that is, to the management board of the company. Acting early, documented with figures and a plan, is the best protection for the company and the management board alike.
A confirmed plan does not change creditors’ rights against the company’s co-debtors and guarantors: the creditor can still claim from the guarantor or co-debtor. The company, however, is released under the plan from obligations to its co-debtors and guarantors (those with recourse claims) in the same way as towards creditors, so a guarantor who has paid can claim from the company only what the plan allows. What exactly this means for an individual guarantor depends on the guarantee contract. That part is checked by a lawyer.
For obligations under commercial contracts, a guarantor is liable as a surety who pays on first demand, unless otherwise agreed. This means that the creditor can claim performance from the company, from the guarantor, or from both at the same time, because such a guarantor is liable as principal debtor for the whole obligation. A guarantor should therefore, before any decision on pre-bankruptcy proceedings, check exactly what was agreed and seek legal advice on their position.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 20.a, Art. 62(4), Art. 110(2)–(4) and Art. 340(2); Civil Obligations Act, Art. 111(3) and (4).
Out-of-court agreement and restructuring
Can a debt be resolved without going to court?
Yes, if rescheduling, a partial write-off, a debt-for-equity swap or other variants are agreed with the key creditors, most often banks and larger suppliers. Such an agreement is faster, cheaper and more discreet than court proceedings.
An out-of-court agreement means that the company and its creditors reach agreement among themselves, without a court. Most often this involves rescheduling (new repayment dates), a grace period, an extension of the term or a partial write-off of the debt. The agreement is usually faster and cheaper, and can remain discreet: customers and suppliers need not know.
The limitation is that the agreement binds only those who sign it. If an important creditor refuses and the others agree, the agreement may fail or be converted into a pre-bankruptcy plan, which, once confirmed, also binds those who opposed it.
That is why out-of-court negotiations and pre-bankruptcy proceedings are often prepared in parallel, so that no time is lost: after 60 days of unexecuted enforcement orders the law presumes inability to pay, which is a ground for bankruptcy (Art. 6(2)). While creditors are talking, the plan and figures are already ready for the court should the talks fail.
A good out-of-court agreement rests on the same foundation as pre-bankruptcy proceedings: an accurate picture of the situation, a realistic plan and a proposal that creditors can verify. Without that, a creditor has no reason to agree.
When is an out-of-court agreement preferable, and when pre-bankruptcy proceedings?
An out-of-court agreement makes sense when there are few creditors, when they are willing to talk, and when the account is not blocked or the blocking is short. It is also the more discreet solution: the agreement remains between the company and its creditors, whereas pre-bankruptcy proceedings are published openly on the courts’ e-Notice Board. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are better when there are many creditors, when some refuse an agreement, or when the company needs protection from enforcement while the plan is being prepared.
There is no rule that always applies, but there are clear criteria. It helps to look at five things: how many creditors there are and how concentrated the debt is, how many days of the blocking of the account have already elapsed, whether assets have been pledged as security, how important discretion is towards customers and suppliers, and whether the key creditors will talk at all.
The out-of-court route suits cases where the key creditors are two or three banks and a few larger suppliers, where those parties know each other and are willing to talk, and where the blocking of the account is short or absent. Its advantages are speed, cost and discretion: the agreement stays between the parties, whereas the decision opening pre-bankruptcy proceedings and the proposed plan are published openly on the courts’ e-Notice Board.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are stronger when there are many creditors, when the debt is larger, or when one of the creditors blocks an agreement. Protection from enforcement and the binding effect of a confirmed plan provide a certainty that an out-of-court agreement does not.
The right answer comes only from analysing the situation: a list of creditors, a cash flow forecast and an assessment of their intentions. Both routes are often prepared in parallel, and the one that proves achievable is pursued.
What is a restructuring plan and what must it contain?
The plan shows how the company will recover and what creditors will receive as a result. It contains an analysis of the situation and of the causes of the difficulties, measures (costs, assets, organisation, financing), a proposal for each class of creditors and a business plan demonstrating that everything is achievable.
A good plan answers three questions: why did the company get into difficulty, what will change, and what will creditors receive. If any one of them is missing, the plan is not convincing.
For pre-bankruptcy proceedings the law also requires a business plan for the current year and the next two, the division of creditors into classes and a description of the effects on employees. Measures may include cost reductions, the sale of non-core assets, organisational changes, new procurement arrangements or new sources of financing.
Creditors accept a plan when it gives them more than bankruptcy would, so that comparison must be convincing and accurate. That is why the calculation of satisfaction under the plan and in bankruptcy is at the centre of the document.
A plan is neither a nicely written document nor a wish list, but an achievable programme. Every figure must have a basis, and the assumptions must be ones that a creditor, the court or a bank can verify. A plan that promises too much loses credibility.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 27.
How long does it take to prepare a restructuring plan?
It depends on the size of the company and how orderly the data is: from a few weeks for smaller companies to several months for more complex cases, counting from the moment you give us the complete and detailed financial documentation needed for the plan. Collecting accurate figures usually takes the most time. For a restructuring plan in pre-bankruptcy proceedings we always meet the statutory deadlines.
The real answer depends on three things: how large and complex the company is, how orderly the data is and how quickly the management board can answer questions. For a smaller company with orderly books, the plan can be ready within a few weeks of receiving complete financial documentation. More complex cases (several companies, pledged assets, many creditors) need several months.
Collecting accurate figures usually takes the most time: the status of liabilities, contracts, security and actual assets. The more orderly the data, the faster the plan. A few days of preparation at the start therefore sometimes save weeks.
In pre-bankruptcy proceedings, if the plan is not filed with the petition, it must be submitted no later than 21 days after the finality of the decision on established and disputed claims. It is therefore best prepared before the petition is filed, not only once the proceedings have begun.
In the written proposal we agree the deadlines at the start, and before that, in the initial consultation, we assess how much time it is likely to take.
The plan is reviewed with you as it is prepared: at every stage you see what has been written and can say what is not right. That way there are no surprises at the end, and the plan is yours, not ours.
Is restructuring public?
It depends on the route. Advice and preparation of the plan are confidential. An out-of-court agreement can remain discreet. Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are public: their opening is published on the courts’ e-Notice Board and entered in the register, so employees, customers and suppliers can learn of it. Communication must therefore be prepared in advance.
A consultation with an adviser is confidential and commits you to nothing. No one but you needs to know that you are enquiring about options. The same applies to preparing the plan: while it lasts, it is an internal matter for the company.
In an out-of-court agreement, discretion is a great advantage. Negotiations are held only with key creditors, often banks, under a confidentiality agreement, so customers and suppliers need not know anything.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings are public. The opening is published and entered in the register, so employees, customers and suppliers will learn of it too. That is why communication is planned in advance: who says what, and when. A well-prepared message (“the procedure is a recovery tool, and business continues”) reduces panic and protects relationships.
When choosing a route, discretion matters, but it is not the only criterion. If an out-of-court agreement fails, the public nature of the proceedings is the price that comes with the advantages of pre-bankruptcy proceedings.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 12 and 34(3).
What is a standstill and how is it agreed?
A standstill is an agreement among creditors not to demand payment or commence enforcement during negotiations, for an agreed period. The company thereby gains time to prepare a plan, and creditors gain assurance that no one will be paid at their expense.
A standstill is an ordinary contract: it binds only those who sign it and does not restrain creditors who have not signed. It is therefore important to include all key creditors, most often banks and larger suppliers.
In our experience it is advisable to tie the standstill to a clear obligation on the company: regular delivery of figures and a plan by an agreed date.
By contrast with a standstill, once pre-bankruptcy proceedings are opened the law itself prohibits enforcement for claims affected by the proceedings, even against creditors who do not agree: for 120 days, and the court may extend that prohibition twice by 90 days each.
Source (for comparison with pre-bankruptcy proceedings): Bankruptcy Act, Art. 68(2).
What is a debt-for-equity swap?
Instead of cash, a creditor receives an ownership stake in the company: part of the debt is converted into shares or equity interests. The company thereby reduces its debt, and the creditor becomes a co-owner.
Such a swap changes the ownership structure, so it needs careful consideration before a decision. It usually requires a decision of the general meeting or the owners, as well as legal and tax review, and owners need to know how much of their stake they will lose.
Creditors accept it when they believe the company will be worth more than they would recover by collecting the debt. A credible plan and figures therefore play a decisive role.
In pre-bankruptcy proceedings a debt-for-equity swap can be part of the restructuring plan. If the company’s existing owners have not passed a resolution that permits it, the court will refuse to confirm the plan. A bank that would acquire through the swap a stake of 20% or more that exceeds 10% of its recognised capital, or a majority stake, must request the consent of the Croatian National Bank before the vote. In our experience banks, as a rule, do not accept a debt-for-equity swap.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 53 and 61(3) point 5.
What if a key creditor refuses an agreement?
An out-of-court agreement binds only those who sign it. If a key creditor refuses, the agreement as a rule fails or can be converted into a pre-bankruptcy plan, which, once confirmed, also binds creditors who opposed it.
That is why, before negotiations, it is important to know who the key creditors are, and what each of them can obtain through an agreement as against bankruptcy. A creditor who would receive almost nothing in bankruptcy often has a reason to accept an agreement.
If it appears that negotiations will not succeed, the plan and figures for pre-bankruptcy proceedings should be prepared in parallel so that no time is lost: after 60 days of unexecuted enforcement orders the law presumes inability to pay, which is a ground for bankruptcy (Art. 6(2)).
Is a partial debt write-off relevant for tax purposes?
Yes, for both sides. Under statutory conditions, a write-off reduces the creditor’s taxable profit, while as a rule it increases the debtor’s, both in pre-bankruptcy proceedings and in an out-of-court agreement.
Pre-bankruptcy proceedings. For the creditor, a write-off under a confirmed restructuring plan is a tax-deductible expense (Bankruptcy Act, Art. 62(3)). For the debtor, the write-off increases income and profit, and that profit is taxable: the tax base is the profit determined under accounting regulations (Corporate Income Tax Act, Art. 5(1)), and the law provides no reduction of the tax base for a write-off in pre-bankruptcy proceedings. In addition, the debtor must retain the profit arising from the write-off until the deadline for fulfilling all obligations under the plan has expired (Bankruptcy Act, Art. 62(2)).
Out-of-court agreement. For the creditor, writing off a receivable is recognised as an expense only if all steps to secure collection have been taken with the care of a prudent businessperson (Corporate Income Tax Act, Art. 9(2)). The law considers this to be the case if the receivable has been the subject of a lawsuit, has been filed in bankruptcy proceedings, or a settlement has been reached in bankruptcy, arbitration or mediation (para. 3). Here too, the write-off increases the debtor’s income and taxable profit. The exception is a write-off by a credit institution: if the receivable was impaired in accordance with the regulations of the Croatian National Bank and the bank waives its right to collect, the amount written off is not taxable income for the debtor (paras. 5 and 6).
Converting debt into equity. If part of the debt is converted into equity instead of being written off, the creditor becomes a shareholder, and as a rule the debtor does not recognise income from a write-off. Whether this is possible and worthwhile depends on the creditors and the owners.
Check the exact tax effect for your company with a tax adviser before signing.
Source: Bankruptcy Act, Art. 62(2) and (3); Corporate Income Tax Act, Art. 5(1) and Art. 9.
Financing and banks
What does a bank look at when a company applies for a loan?
A bank essentially asks three questions: can the company repay the loan from its business, what happens if something goes wrong, and does it trust the management board. It looks for the answers in the financial statements, the cash flow, existing borrowing, security and the quality of the plan.
The first question is repayment: does the company generate enough cash from ordinary business to repay the loan alongside all its other obligations. That is why the bank looks not only at profit but also at cash flow.
The second question is security: what if the business deteriorates? This is where collateral (pledges, guarantees) and risk assessment come in. The third question is trust: does the management board know its business, does it provide accurate information and does it keep to agreements.
The usual requests are financial statements for the last two to three years, data for the current year, a list of loans and other obligations with the terms on which they were granted, the largest customers and suppliers, projected profit and loss accounts and cash flows, and an explanation of the purpose of the loan and the source of repayment. For investments there is also a business plan or investment study, cost estimates and permits. Each bank has its own list, but the logic is the same.
What helps: orderly and consistent data, a clear purpose for the loan, a realistic repayment plan and openness about weak points. A bank approves a request much more readily when the risks are named and addressed than when it has to find them itself.
Source: experience from banking practice.
What is the difference between a working capital loan and an investment loan?
A working capital loan is short-term and finances current operations: inventory, receivables from customers and payments to suppliers. An investment loan is long-term and finances investments that are repaid over years: equipment, premises, larger projects.
The rule is simple: what returns cash quickly is financed short-term, what returns it slowly is financed long-term. Inventory and customer receivables turn over within months, so a short-term loan suits them. Equipment, a building or a new plant earn money for years, so a long-term loan suits them.
A common mistake is to finance a long-term investment with a short-term loan. Repayment then falls due before the investment starts to earn, and even a healthy company runs into liquidity problems. Conversely, a long-term loan for current needs is more expensive than it needs to be.
Besides loans there are other forms: factoring (selling receivables to a bank or a specialised company), bank guarantees, letters of credit and leasing. Each solves a different problem, and the right choice depends on the business.
An adviser helps to assess how much funding is needed, for how long and how to secure it at the lowest cost, before the application is even submitted.
Is a business plan always needed for a loan?
Not always. For smaller short-term loans, financial statements and a good track record of cooperation are often enough for a bank. For investments, larger amounts or companies with a short history, a business plan or study is almost always needed.
A bank looks at how far it can trust the company’s future. If the company has been operating for years with orderly, known and consistent results, its history stands in for a plan. For new companies, large investments or unusual requests, history does not explain the future, so a plan is needed.
A good plan is written not for the bank but for the management board: it shows how much cash is really needed, and when and how it is repaid. The bank then understands it faster and decides faster. For investments the plan usually contains a forecast of income and costs by year, cash flow and profitability indicators.
What banks dislike: a plan with overly optimistic assumptions, with no analysis of what happens if sales fall short, or with figures that do not agree with the rest of the business. A realistic plan with named risks is more convincing than a perfect one.
If you are not sure whether you need a plan, the answer is usually found in the first conversation with the bank or an adviser.
A plan does not have to be long. For a smaller loan a few pages with a clear purpose, expected income and a repayment calculation may be enough; it is more important that it is accurate than that it is extensive.
The bank has rejected the loan application. What now?
First find out the exact reason: the figures, security, amount, maturity or the way the application was presented. Often, with better preparation, a different structure or a different bank, a solution can be found.
A rejection is not the end. The first step is a discussion with the bank about the reason: are figures missing, is the amount too large, the maturity unsuitable, the security insufficient or the application unclearly presented. Often the reason can be remedied.
Then look at which part you can change: a smaller or staged amount, a different maturity, additional security, a better explained purpose. Sometimes another form of financing suits the business better, for example factoring instead of a loan.
Write down the reasons the bank gave you and compare them with what you submitted. Sometimes it turns out the application was sound, but the bank did not receive the information it needs, and then it is enough to supplement the documentation.
Another bank or a different approach sometimes produces a different answer, because banks assess risk and sectors differently. It is important that all banks receive the same accurate data.
Sometimes the honest answer is that a loan is not advisable at that moment and that the business or its capital structure must first be put in order. That too is a valuable conclusion, because it protects the company from debt it cannot carry.
Does it make sense to talk to several banks?
As a rule, yes. Banks assess risk, sectors and security differently, so terms can differ considerably. It is important that all banks receive the same figures and the same documentation, so that the offers can be fairly compared.
Every bank has its own policy on the sectors, company sizes and types of collateral it prefers. What one bank finds unattractive may be routine business for another, so offers can differ considerably in both price and terms.
The comparison should cover not just the interest rate but the total cost of financing, that is, the effective interest rate (EIR), which includes interest and fees. Also compare fees, maturity, grace period, required collateral and the company’s contractual obligations to the bank, for example the financial covenants it must maintain. A cheaper interest rate with strict conditions can end up more expensive.
Recommended approach: prepare one set of documents and give it to all the banks, so that the offers are comparable. Decide in advance what matters most (price, flexibility, speed) and weigh the offers accordingly.
Negotiation is part of the process: terms can often be improved, especially when you hold a concrete, comparable offer.
Take care not to flood the market with the same enquiry without a clear strategy. It is better first to select two or three banks that fit your business by size and sector, and only then widen the circle.
How long does it take to prepare a loan application?
If the data is in order, preparation takes from a few days for simpler loans to several weeks for investments that require a study. The bank’s decision follows and depends on the bank, the amount and the complexity.
The time depends on three things: how orderly the data is, how complex the request is, and whether a business plan or study is required. For a simpler short-term loan with orderly reports, preparation can take a few days. For an investment requiring a study, estimates and permits, it takes weeks.
Most of the time usually goes on collecting and reconciling data: financial statements, a schedule of liabilities, contracts with customers and suppliers, pro-forma invoices. The better this is prepared, the faster and more convincing the application.
The bank’s decision comes after that and depends neither on us nor on you: it depends on the bank, the amount, the complexity and the collateral. You should therefore not count on a decision in advance, but plan with a reserve.
Advice: start preparing before you need the funds. A company that applies for credit at the last minute has a weaker negotiating position.
The time until disbursement also depends on the security: if a pledge or a registration in a register is required, that takes additional time. Allow a time buffer in your plan and ask the bank in advance what the steps are after approval.
Can a company that has been in difficulty get a bank loan again?
It can, but the bank will look at what has changed: results after restructuring, punctuality of payments and the realism of the new plan. A convincing and accurate account of the recovery is decisive.
Difficulties in the past do not close the door for good, but the bank will want evidence that the situation is genuinely different. It looks at several things: whether the causes of the difficulties have been removed, what the results are after restructuring, whether the company pays on time and whether it sticks to the agreed plan.
What helps most is a clear narrative backed by figures: what went wrong, what was changed and what that shows over the last several periods. A convincing and accurate account of the recovery matters more than any promise.
Banks look for a period of demonstrated orderly operation, as a rule two years.
It also helps if the company monitors its figures regularly, for example through a monthly review, because the bank then sees that the management board has the situation under control. Sometimes the first step is a smaller, shorter-term loan, which rebuilds trust.
If you are in restructuring, the agreements with creditors often determine when and how you may borrow again. This should be checked before talking to the bank.
Can state guarantees or programmes (e.g. HAMAG-BICRO) help with financing?
They can, provided the company is creditworthy. HAMAG-BICRO offers guarantees that cover part of a bank loan, so a company without sufficient collateral of its own can get a loan more easily. HAMAG-BICRO also grants some loans directly. Programmes change, so only those published on the HAMAG-BICRO website are valid.
In the case of a guarantee, the entrepreneur submits the application to the bank, which processes the loan application and then submits a guarantee request to HAMAG-BICRO. The bank still assesses repayment capacity, and the guarantee covers part of its risk. For direct loans, the application is submitted to HAMAG-BICRO.
Before applying, check the programme’s conditions, its purpose (investments, working capital) and whether the company can meet the requirements. We help prepare the data and the discussion with the bank.
Source: HAMAG-BICRO, hamagbicro.hr (Questions and answers – Guarantees; ERDF individual and portfolio guarantees).
What is collateral and what security do banks require?
Collateral is security that the bank requires to be sure the loan will be repaid. It can be a pledge (mortgage) over real estate, a pledge over movable property and the like, receivables, a guarantee from the owner or another person, and other types of security.
What the bank will require depends on the size and purpose of the loan, the condition of the company and the bank itself. The better the quality of the security, the more favourable the terms often are.
Before signing, you need to know exactly what is being pledged or guaranteed and what that means if the company cannot repay the loan.
What does it mean when a bank classifies a loan as “non-performing”?
It means the bank has classified the loan among those in which the debtor is not meeting its obligations. Under the European regulation, this happens when the debtor is more than 90 days past due on a material amount, or when the bank judges that the debtor is unlikely to repay its debt in full without realisation of the collateral.
Indicators of “unlikely to pay” include, among others, a significant value adjustment of the loan, distressed restructuring involving a write-off of principal or interest, and the opening of bankruptcy proceedings.
In our experience: once a loan becomes non-performing, the bank usually moves it to a dedicated workout unit, requests new figures and a plan as well as additional collateral, and is reluctant to approve new exposures, although opportunities for alternative negotiations also open up. It is therefore important to speak to the bank before arrears reach that threshold.
Source: Regulation (EU) No 575/2013, Art. 178.
What are covenants in a loan agreement, and what happens if the company breaches them?
Covenants are obligations under a loan agreement that the company must comply with for as long as the loan lasts: for example, a maximum permitted level of debt (often as a ratio of net debt to EBITDA), minimum coverage of loan repayments from cash flow (DSCR), or a prohibition on taking on new debt or granting collateral without the bank’s consent. If the company breaches them, the bank is entitled to the measures provided for in the agreement, up to and including terminating the loan.
Financial covenants are measured on the basis of the financial statements, most often annually or semi-annually, and the company provides the bank with a compliance certificate. In addition, there are other obligations: regular submission of reports, keeping the ownership structure unchanged, or channelling turnover through the bank.
The consequences of a breach are set out in the agreement: a higher interest rate, additional collateral, earlier maturity or termination of the loan. Banks often agree to waive or amend a covenant, especially when the company raises the problem itself in good time and offers a plan. That is why covenants are worth monitoring in advance, not only when the bank asks for a compliance certificate.
Is the owner personally liable after signing a guarantee for the company’s loan?
Yes. A guarantor is liable for the entire obligation they have guaranteed, unless liability is limited, and with their personal assets. For obligations under commercial contracts, such as a loan to a company, a guarantor is as a rule liable as a joint and several surety (jamac platac): the bank can demand payment directly from the guarantor without waiting for the company.
The guarantor’s obligation cannot be greater than the debtor’s obligation, but it also includes increases due to the debtor’s default, such as default interest, and the necessary costs incurred by the creditor in collecting from the debtor. If there are several guarantors, they are jointly and severally liable. A reduction of the debtor’s obligation in bankruptcy proceedings does not reduce the guarantor’s obligation: the guarantor remains liable for the full amount of their obligation.
A guarantee is also often given by signing a promissory note (zadužnica) or a blank promissory note as a joint and several surety. The bank can then submit the promissory note directly to FINA for collection from the guarantor’s account and, on the basis of it, also seek enforcement against the guarantor’s other assets, without first bringing a lawsuit.
A guarantee does not end simply because the owner has sold their stake or left the management board. Before signing, it is worth knowing the amount and the period for which you are guaranteeing, and for existing guarantees, how they can be replaced or reduced.
Source: Civil Obligations Act, Art. 104, 109, 111, 112 and 114; Enforcement Act, Art. 214 and 215.
Can a loan rescheduling be agreed before the company starts falling behind on repayments?
Yes, and that is the best time to do it. A bank agrees to change the repayment terms more readily while the company is paying on time and can show a realistic plan than once the arrears have already started.
Rescheduling can mean extending the repayment period, a grace period on principal, a repayment schedule adapted to the seasonality of the business, or consolidating several loans into one. The bank will ask for the reasons, up-to-date figures and a cash flow plan showing that the new repayment schedule is feasible.
The bank may treat such a change as a restructuring due to the debtor’s financial difficulties (forbearance), which affects how it views the company in future applications. That is why the request should be prepared so that it clearly shows the reason and the way out.
A company in good times
Why would a company carry out a financial review when business is going well?
Because risks are easiest to see and cheapest to address while no one is exerting pressure. When business is going well, figures are rarely examined, and that is precisely when habits form that cause damage later: slower collection, growing inventory, or loans that do not track cash flow.
A review does not mean that something is wrong with the company. It means the owner knows where the company stands: how much cash actually remains, how much of a weaker year the company can withstand, and what the bank would see if it read its financial statements today.
The second reason is choice. A company that knows its figures can choose when to borrow, when to invest and how to approach the bank. A company that confronts its figures only when already in difficulty chooses among fewer options, and under greater time pressure.
A review can be carried out once or periodically, for example annually. The scope is agreed in advance and in writing.
How do you recognise the first signs of deteriorating cash flow?
It usually shows first in the way cash moves, and only later in the result. Customers pay later and later, inventory builds up, and you increasingly wait for collections before paying suppliers, wages or taxes.
A company can show a profit on paper and still lack cash in its account. That is why cash flow is a more reliable indicator than earnings. Warning signs include a lengthening average collection period, increasing reliance on the overdraft, delays to suppliers, a falling margin at constant turnover, and a single customer accounting for a large share of revenue.
None of these signs on its own indicates difficulty. Together, or when they persist, they show a direction. If you see them, it is best to prepare a cash flow forecast for the next few months and test what would happen under a downside scenario, while there is still time to react.
Can banks change loan terms when a company is doing well?
The terms are set by the contract, and how they can be changed depends on that contract and on regulation. It is therefore important to know what your contracts say, rather than assume that the terms will remain unchanged.
In practice, companies often sign loan agreements containing provisions the bank monitors: certain financial ratios, deadlines for delivering reports, collateral. If the business or circumstances change, those ratios may deteriorate, and the bank then opens a discussion on the terms. Such a discussion is easier if the company initiates it itself, with a clear picture.
What exactly your contract says and what it permits is reviewed by a lawyer with sight of the contract. We help you understand the financial side: which ratios the bank monitors, how far you are from the limits, and how you will appear to the bank before it notices.
As an owner, do I need to understand finance?
You do not need to be a finance professional, but you do need to understand a few things: how much cash is actually coming in and going out, how indebted you are, and what the bank reads from your financial statements. All major decisions rest on that.
Bookkeeping and the accountant do their job, but the decisions are yours. If you do not understand the figures, you rely on someone else’s interpretation. That can be fine, but your decision is then only as good as that interpretation.
Training for owners and managers is therefore not an accounting course. The aim is that you know what to ask, what the answers mean and when it is time to call in a specialist. We work with examples from your own company, in a way that makes sense to people who run a business rather than to finance specialists.
How should you prepare for the sale of a company?
Start preparing as early as possible, because a buyer asks the same questions a bank would: how much the company really earns, how dependent it is on the owner and key customers, and what lies hidden in the liabilities.
Financial preparation covers orderly and comprehensible figures, a review of liabilities and contracts, a clear picture of how dependent the company is on the owner and a few customers, and a realistic expectation of what the buyer will request. A company that is well prepared finds it easier to justify its price and reaches agreement faster.
Consider also what is not in the figures: what the owner wants after the sale, how long they wish to remain involved, and what matters to them besides price.
The legal and tax aspects of a sale are handled by lawyers and tax advisers, with whom we cooperate with your consent. We do not value companies as a certified appraiser.
What if the company passes to heirs, that is, to children or family?
Transferring a company within a family is not only a financial decision. Alongside the figures, roles, expectations and relationships need to be discussed, and that is often what determines whether the transfer succeeds.
The most common questions are not technical. Who will manage, and who will own? What does the successor expect, and what does the person handing over expect? How will the relationship between parents and children change when they become colleagues and someone else makes the decisions? What about the other children who are not joining the company? If these matters are not discussed, tensions surface only when they are hard to resolve.
We help you discuss this openly, with the figures on the table: how much the company can pay out, how to finance it and what it means for each person. This is not psychological counselling or therapy. The legal and tax aspects of the transfer are handled by lawyers and tax advisers, with whom we cooperate with your consent.
Does a review always end with a proposal for further cooperation?
No. The review ends with findings and recommendations, and the decision on what to do next remains yours. If the company is in good shape, we will say so.
A review does not oblige you to cooperate further. We may conclude that nothing needs to be done, or that it is enough for you to change a few habits yourself. It is also possible that the findings show areas in which assistance makes sense, and we then propose what that would involve, how long it would take and what it would cost, in writing and in advance.
If it turns out that a question falls outside our field, for example legal or tax, we will say so immediately and refer you to the appropriate specialists.
How often should a financial review be carried out?
For most companies, a thorough review once a year, with the key figures (cash, collections, liabilities) monitored monthly. More often when the company is growing rapidly or implementing a plan after restructuring.
The goal is not paperwork but timely warning. If the figures are reviewed monthly with the owner and the management board, problems are visible while they are still small.
One to two pages are sufficient for the key figures. Monthly financial monitoring is exactly that: a regular, brief review with a proposal for measures when the figures deviate.
Why is cash flow important even when the company is profitable?
Profit is a calculation on paper; cash flow is real money. A company can be profitable and still run out of cash for wages, taxes and suppliers.
The most common causes: customers pay slowly, cash is tied up in inventory, growth absorbs cash, or loans are being repaid that are not an expense in the income statement.
That is why banks and creditors look at cash flow, not just profit. A short-term forecast, week by week, shows when cash will run short before it happens.
Does a company need a permanent CFO, or is an external adviser enough?
Many small and medium-sized companies have no need for a permanent CFO. It is sufficient for the owner to receive an expert view of the figures regularly, once a month.
A permanent CFO is justified when the workload is large and complex enough to occupy a full-time position. Until then, an external adviser can fill the role: reviewing the figures, flagging risks and proposing measures.
An external adviser does not replace bookkeeping or audit, and decisions and responsibility remain with the management board. Monthly financial monitoring describes how this looks in practice.
How can a company protect itself when it depends on a few large customers?
The first step is to know what share of revenue and collections the largest customers account for, and what would happen to the cash if one of them paid late or left. The measures depend on the business, from payment terms and securing collection to gradually broadening the customer base. Which of them make sense for your company is something we assess in our Customer and collection risk service.
What is a cash flow stress test?
A stress test shows what would happen to a company’s cash in a weaker scenario: a fall in sales, a delay in payment by a large customer, or rising interest rates. The answer is how long the company can hold out and where the limit lies beyond which action is needed. We tailor the scenarios to each company.
Advisory and oversight
What is business advisory and how does it differ from accounting?
Accounting records what has already happened, whereas business advisory helps you decide what to do next, in both the financial and the operational aspects of your business. We look at figures, risks and opportunities, and you take the decision.
Business advisory is a second opinion when a decision matters: a new investment, borrowing, a fall in sales, or a discussion with a bank, partner or investor.
You receive an independent view of the figures and risks, a comparison of the options, a reasoned recommendation and, where needed, an implementation plan. We advise on business and financial matters, while legal and tax advice is given by lawyers and tax advisers.
What is monthly financial monitoring and who needs it?
Once a month we go through the figures with the owner and the management board: cash in the account, collections from customers, liabilities and deviations from plan. Problems are thus identified in time, and decisions are based on figures.
It is particularly useful during and after a restructuring, when the implementation of the plan needs to be monitored, in a period of rapid growth, when cash often disappears into inventory and receivables, and when the company has no chief financial officer. For such companies we also offer the role of an external part-time chief financial officer (CFO), in an advisory capacity, without joining the management board, unless this is specifically agreed.
You receive an overview of the key figures on one to two pages, a comparison with the plan, a warning of liquidity risks, a meeting with the owner and the management board, and a proposal for measures when the figures deviate. Monitoring does not replace bookkeeping, audit or a supervisory board.
What is a short-term cash flow forecast and when is it needed?
It is a week-by-week forecast of cash, usually for the next quarter (about 13 weeks): how much cash is coming in, how much is going out, and when there is a shortfall. It provides time for decisions before the cash runs out.
It is most needed when account blocking is imminent or already in place, when preparing pre-bankruptcy proceedings or negotiations with creditors, and when a bank requests a liquidity review.
The forecast shows the critical weeks and the amounts that are missing, and proposes measures: collection, deferrals and payment priorities. It is based on the management board’s estimates and does not guarantee that the inflows will materialise.
When does a company need crisis management?
When the crisis is greater than the management board can handle alongside its regular work: a sudden fall in revenue, account blocking and creditor pressure, or when there is simply too much work for the people running the business.
We help the management board run the agreed crisis workstreams: cash, creditors, cost-saving measures and the recovery plan. At the outset we assess the situation, the cash position and the most urgent decisions, then prepare an action plan (what, who and by when) and monitor its implementation regularly.
We work as advisers alongside the management board: decisions and the legal responsibility of the management board remain with it. If a temporary role on the board or in the company is needed, it is agreed separately and reviewed legally.
What does bespoke advisory include?
Bespoke advisory is for situations that fit no standard category. Together we agree the scope, deadlines and way of working, according to your company’s needs.
It can be a combination of several services in one engagement, a one-off question such as a second opinion or a short analysis, or a long-term cooperation.
Scope, deadlines and fee are agreed in advance and in writing, and you know in advance who you are working with. If a task falls outside our field, we will say so immediately.
What is the purpose of training and coaching for owners and managers?
An owner or manager does not have to be a finance professional, but must understand the figures on which they base their decisions: cash flow, indebtedness, loan terms and what the bank sees when it reads their financial statements.
Training is tailored to the company and the participants, and where possible draws on examples from your own business. Coaching is a one-to-one discussion about a specific decision, from investment and borrowing to working with the bank.
Training and coaching do not lead to a formal qualification or a public document and do not replace accounting, tax or legal services.
When does it make sense to seek a second opinion before a major decision?
When a decision ties up a large amount of money or the company for years, and the information comes from a party with an interest in the deal going ahead: the seller, an equipment supplier, an investor or the team that prepared the project. It also applies when you are not sure: about the data, about the estimates of the people who prepared the decision, or simply about the step itself.
Typical examples are a major investment, a new loan or lease, entering a new line of business, a large contract with a single customer, or buying a company. A second opinion checks the assumptions on which the decision is based, the impact on cash and debt, and the risks that are not in the foreground.
An independent view then either confirms that you are on the right track, so you can make the decision more calmly and with more confidence, or shows in good time what still needs to be checked. It does not replace the management board’s decision, but gives it a firmer basis. It is most valuable before signing, while the terms can still be changed.
What does an external part-time chief financial officer (CFO) do?
They take on part of a chief financial officer’s work, to the extent the company needs: monitoring the figures, taking part in planning and discussions with banks, and helping the management board with important financial decisions.
This solution suits companies that have outgrown bookkeeping alone, but do not yet need, or cannot yet justify, a full-time chief financial officer.
The role is advisory: we do not join the management board and do not sign on behalf of the company, unless this is specifically agreed. Bookkeeping and tax returns remain with the accountants. The scope, deadlines and fees are agreed in writing.
Can confidential and personal data be entered safely into artificial intelligence (AI) tools?
Yes, with conditions. Artificial intelligence (AI) tools can make work easier and faster, but only with clear rules: which data may be entered, into which tool, and under what terms of the provider. The safest approach is to enter data from which names and other details that could identify individuals, the company or business partners have been removed.
The risks are not only legal. Data entered into a tool is stored by the provider and, depending on the terms of use, may be used for further training of the tool or may be disclosed in the event of a breach. That is why, before using a tool, you need to know where the data is processed, how long it is kept, who has access to it, and whether the provider uses it for training. Business plans generally regulate this more strictly than free plans or those for private users.
Personal data is subject to the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). If the tool provider processes personal data on behalf of the company, a data processing agreement is required, and the company must ensure an appropriate level of security. Pseudonymised data, where names have been replaced with codes or labels, is still personal data, while the GDPR does not apply to data that has been genuinely anonymised so that the person can no longer be identified.
Trade secrets and partners’ confidential information are also protected by non-disclosure agreements, so you should check whether those agreements allow the use of external tools. The EU Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act) also requires companies that use artificial intelligence (AI) systems to ensure a sufficient level of AI literacy among their staff.
With such rules, AI becomes an advantage rather than a risk. Legal questions of data protection remain with lawyers.
Source: Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Art. 4(5), Art. 28 and 32 and Recital 26; Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act), Art. 4.
Can a company rely on what artificial intelligence (AI) calculates or suggests?
As an aid, yes, but not without checking. Artificial intelligence (AI) tools are still learning and make mistakes, so the result must be checked by an expert before a decision is based on it. Responsibility for the decision lies with whoever accepted the result, not with the tool.
AI can produce wrong information: a convincing but incorrect answer, a wrong figure or a regulation that does not exist, and do so very confidently. That is why it is worth checking the sources, recalculating the key figures and comparing the result with your own knowledge of the business.
Used well, AI saves time on preparation, summarising and first drafts, while the expert and the management board retain judgement and the decision.
When and if we use AI tools in our work, we check everything, and responsibility for the advice remains with us.
Transactions and special services
What is factoring and when does it pay off?
Factoring is a transaction in which a provider (a factoring company or a bank) purchases a company’s receivables from its customers, with or without recourse. The company thus receives its cash earlier, at the cost of fees and interest, instead of waiting for the customer to pay.
In recourse factoring the company guarantees to the provider the customer’s obligation, whereas in non-recourse factoring the provider bears the entire collection risk. A factoring agreement must be concluded in writing. Factoring may be carried out by factoring companies with the approval of the competent agency, and by credit institutions.
It pays off when fast liquidity is worth more than the fee and interest: for example, when customers have longer agreed payment terms (they pay more slowly) and the cash is needed for purchases or wages. It is assessed on your figures and your contract. We advise which instrument suits the need, prepare the data for the bank and compare terms.
Source: Factoring Act (OG 94/14, 85/15, 41/16), Arts. 2, 4, 10, 13, 18 and 20.
What are guarantees and letters of credit, and who needs them?
A bank guarantee is a written undertaking by a bank to pay the beneficiary a specified amount on the beneficiary’s written demand if the conditions of the guarantee are met. It most often serves as security that the other party will perform the contract. A letter of credit is an instrument under which a bank pays the beneficiary when the beneficiary presents documents that comply with its terms, and it is used in international trade.
A guarantee is most often required by a contracting authority or a supplier in public procurement and large contracts, as a bid bond, a performance bond, an advance payment guarantee or a payment guarantee. A guarantee is an independent obligation of the bank, separate from the underlying transaction in connection with which it was issued. That is why, under a guarantee payable “on first demand”, the bank pays at the beneficiary’s request, without the debtor being able to object. As a rule, payment can be stopped only by the beneficiary of the guarantee, if they withdraw their demand for payment under the guarantee, or by an interim measure of the court that has jurisdiction under the wording of the guarantee.
A letter of credit is used by a company doing business with an unknown partner abroad. Most often four parties are involved: the buyer and its bank, which opens the letter of credit, and the seller and its bank; less often, both parties use the same bank. The banks do not check the goods, but the documents: the seller presents the shipping documents through its bank, and payment is made when the documents comply with the terms of the letter of credit. In this way, payment is secured for both sides. International letters of credit are governed by the rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (UCP 600).
We advise on the financial side: which instrument fits the need, what it costs and what obligations the company takes on.
Source: Civil Obligations Act, Art. 1028–1038 (letters of credit) and Art. 1039–1043 (guarantees); International Chamber of Commerce, UCP 600 (letters of credit).
What does a financial analysis check when buying a company?
We help the buyer of a company or a stake check the financial position before signing: the result, cash flow, debts and other obligations, and the realism of the seller’s plan.
The analysis covers the financial statements and the quality of earnings, indebtedness, liabilities and potential future liabilities, an estimate of cash flow and capital needs after the purchase, and a list of financial risks and questions for the seller. It also provides a financial basis for price negotiations.
We work for the buyer. The analysis is based on data supplied by the seller and is not an audit. For the legal and tax aspects of the transaction, we recommend engaging lawyers and tax specialists.
What is a receivables portfolio and what do you advise on when buying or selling one?
A receivables portfolio is a set of receivables sold or bought as a whole. We advise the buyer or the seller: we assess the value of the portfolio and advise on purchase and sale, most often for buyers.
We analyse the structure of the portfolio (debtors, amounts, age and security), estimate expected recoveries and value, review the key risks, and advise on preparing an offer and in negotiations.
In a single transaction we hold only one role. We do not provide legal or tax services, we do not service receivables and we do not take over collection.
Working with us
What does the initial consultation involve, and does it commit me to anything?
In the initial consultation we hear what the matter concerns and honestly tell you whether we can help and how. The consultation is confidential and does not commit you to anything.
The initial consultation lasts as long as it takes us to understand the matter. We mostly listen and ask questions: what happened, how much time you have, what matters most to you and what you have already tried.
At the end we honestly tell you whether we can help and what the work would involve. Sometimes the answer is that you do not need an adviser, or that you need a lawyer more, and we tell you so. If cooperation makes sense, you receive a written proposal: what we will do, by when and for what fee.
Until then you do not have to sign or pay anything. The decision is yours, when you are ready.
The consultation can take place by phone, by video or in person. Everything you say stays between us.
If you do not know where to start, it is enough to write to us in two or three sentences what is happening and how urgent it is. Urgent situations, such as account blocking or a notice of enforcement, we try to take on first.
What should I prepare for the initial consultation?
What you have at hand is enough: the latest financial statements, a list of major liabilities and creditors and, if the account is blocked, data from FINA. If something is missing, we will agree together what to collect and how.
You do not need perfectly organised documentation. The initial consultation serves to form a general picture, so what you have at hand is sufficient.
It is useful to bring: the latest annual financial statements (the GFI-POD form for companies, usually the annual income tax return (DOH) for sole traders) and, if available, reports for the current year; a list of major liabilities and creditors (banks, suppliers, tax and other public authorities, employees); loan and security agreements, if you have them; and, if the account is blocked, data on the enforcement grounds from FINA.
Also prepare a few sentences about what led to the current situation and what you expect. That is the most important part: the figures say what is, and you say why and where you want to go.
If something is missing, that is not a problem. Together we will agree what needs to be collected and in what order, so that you do not waste time on things that are not important.
You do not have to explain or justify anything in advance. If it is uncomfortable to talk about some things, that is understandable, and we are used to it. The more openly you describe how things stand, the better we can assess what is possible.
Is everything I say confidential?
Yes. Everything you tell us stays between us. We share information with lawyers, tax advisers, auditors and other specialists only with your consent and when it is needed for your matter.
Confidentiality is the foundation of this work. An owner or a management board who tell us how things really stand must know that it goes no further. That is why we treat the consultation and the information you entrust to us as a trade secret. If you wish, we will also sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) before the first consultation.
When your matter requires a lawyer, tax adviser, auditor or other specialist, we share data with them only with your consent and only as far as necessary. We involve no one without your knowledge.
When we work for you, we do not advise creditors in the same matter. In a single matter we hold only one role, and that is part of the trust we owe you.
Data you send us through the form or by e-mail is used only to answer your enquiry. More on this is in the privacy policy.
Do not send sensitive documents, such as financial statements or contracts, through the form on this website. After the initial consultation we will agree a secure method of exchange together.
Do you also work with companies that are not in difficulty?
Yes. For growing businesses we help with business plans, investment studies, preparing loan applications and discussions with banks.
Difficulty is not the only reason to engage an adviser. Growing businesses often need expert help precisely because growth consumes cash: more sales means more inventory and receivables, so the right financing is needed at the right time.
We help you decide how much funding is needed and in what form, prepare a business plan or investment study, prepare a loan application so that the bank understands it quickly, and conduct discussions with banks. Experience of corporate lending at a bank helps make the application what the bank expects.
For companies that want to keep track of their position, we also offer monthly financial monitoring: a regular review of the figures with the management board, so that problems are noticed in time.
Growth does not have to mean large amounts. Even for smaller loans and short-term financing it pays to have a prepared application that the bank quickly understands, because it decides faster on a clearly presented case.
We work for the company, not for the bank.
Are you affiliated with any bank?
No. We work with all banks, but iNOVA is independent and works only for the client, so we advise what is best for the company, not for any particular bank.
Independence matters to us. We are not part of any bank, we receive no fees from banks and we do not represent their products. We work exclusively for the company that engaged us.
This has practical consequences: when we advise on a loan, we compare the offers of several banks and recommend what best suits your business, not what would earn someone a higher commission.
Banking experience means we know how banks think and what they require, so we can prepare an application in a way that is easier to understand. It does not mean that we have any relationships or obligations towards banks.
We will also tell you honestly when a loan is not the right solution, or when another bank is the better choice.
If you wish, at the initial consultation you can ask anything you like about our way of working, fees and relationship with banks. You get the answers before you sign anything.
Do you also work with sole traders?
Yes, where we can help. Our services are primarily intended for companies, but we also speak to sole traders, especially about financing and restructuring their business.
Sole traders have similar needs to smaller companies: plans, financing, discussions with banks and, if necessary, restructuring. The difference is that a sole trader is liable with their entire property, so the consequences of decisions are more personal.
Our services are primarily intended for companies, but we speak to sole traders and assess each case individually. In the initial consultation we see whether we can help and what would make sense.
A sole trader in difficulty can also enter pre-bankruptcy proceedings, as an individual debtor, under rules that are more complex than for companies. That is why it is even more important for a sole trader to review the figures early and with expert help.
Legal and tax aspects here too are handled by lawyers and tax advisers, while we prepare the financial part.
If you are a sole trader and are not sure where you stand, it is enough to begin with a simple review: how much cash is coming in over the next few months, how much is going out and which obligations fall due. That alone shows whether it is a temporary squeeze or a real problem.
How much does your service cost and how is it charged?
There is no price list, because we tailor every service. The fee is agreed before work starts, according to the scope and complexity of the job. The initial consultation does not commit you to anything.
How long does the cooperation last?
It depends on the job: from a one-off discussion or a short analysis to a long-term cooperation. The duration is agreed in advance, together with the scope and the fee.
A one-off task, for example a second opinion or an assessment of the position, ends with delivery of the findings and a discussion of them. A restructuring plan or support in proceedings takes longer, while monthly monitoring is an ongoing engagement that continues for as long as it is useful.
In every case, the scope, deadlines and fee are agreed in advance.
Do you also work outside Zagreb and remotely?
Yes. We work outside Zagreb and remotely. The initial consultation can be by phone, by video or in person.
What can be done remotely is done remotely, and we are glad to hold meetings at the client’s premises. On site it is easier to see how the business really works, key people and documentation are in the same place, and questions are resolved immediately. This saves time and leads to more concrete conclusions.
Who will work on my matter?
iNOVA works on your matter: the founder together with a team of analysts and associates. Who leads the day-to-day work is agreed in advance, and we work with clients personally and openly.
For legal, tax and audit questions we involve lawyers, tax advisers and other specialists as needed, and only with your consent.
Do you guarantee the outcome?
No. No one can honestly guarantee an outcome: creditors and the court decide on a plan, and the bank on a loan. We commit to the agreed work and deadlines, not to the outcome.
What we can guarantee is orderly preparation: a clear plan and open communication, based on the figures we receive from the company, your bookkeeping or your auditor. Decisions and responsibility for running the company remain with the management board.
Sources
- Bankruptcy Act, consolidated text (OG 71/15, 104/17, 36/22, 27/24)
- Act Amending the Bankruptcy Act, OG 36/22
- Judicial Academy: Pre-bankruptcy proceedings, the second amendment of the Bankruptcy Act (2022)
- FINA: Pre-bankruptcy proceedings
- FINA: Bankruptcy proceedings
- High Commercial Court, Pž-1925/2023
- Civil Obligations Act (guarantee, bank guarantee)
- Enforcement Act (promissory note)
- General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 on artificial intelligence (AI Act)
The content of the Knowledge base is a copyrighted work of iNOVA. Short quotations are permitted provided the source is credited (iNOVA, Knowledge base, inova.com.hr) and the website is linked. Reproducing larger parts or any other use requires our written permission. More in the Legal Notice.